Why We Say No to AI and Dropshipping
Share
The tabletop market has changed. You open any webshop today, and you are immediately flooded with the exact same products. Mass-produced plastic from overseas factories. Digital storefronts filled to the brim with AI-generated art. Generic resin towers that look identical to a hundred others.
The industry has found a way to make tabletop gear cheap, fast, and highly profitable. People often ask us why we do not do the same. Why do we insist on hand-drawing our grid paper? Why do we 3D design and print our trackers locally in Rotterdam?
The answer is simple. We want to protect the guild. We want to protect the magic of the kitchen table.
The Analog Sanctuary
For us, Dungeons & Dragons has always been an analog sanctuary. It is a rare excuse to put your phones and laptops away. You gather around a table with your friends, you roll physical math rocks, and you exist entirely in the moment.
That experience usually starts at a kitchen table. It begins with printed character sheets, homemade props, and improvised tools. There is a specific kind of magic in that raw, tactile creativity. When you replace all of that with mass-produced dropship items or cheap stickerslap products, you lose something vital. You lose the soul of the game.
The Elephant in the Matchbox
We never actually set out to start a business. We just wanted to fix our own problems at the table.
Years ago, we tried writing a massive, highly ambitious campaign setting in the Forgotten Realms. We tried to cram thirty pages of deep lore into a single one-shot adventure. It did not work. It was not a dramatic failure with shouting at the table. It was just a quiet realization that we were trying to force an elephant into a matchbox. Our ambition had drifted too far from what is actually useful during a game.
That realization changed everything. We pivoted completely and created our first 3for5e modules. Three pages. Short, punchy, and instantly usable. No fluff. Just the mechanics and the story you actually need to run a great session.
That exact mindset spilled over into our physical products.
Function First. Looking Cool is a Byproduct.
There is a golden rule at Cacklin Slayers: function always comes first. Looking cool is just a byproduct.
The very first version of our Initiative Tracker was brutally functional. It was a block of plastic that solved a sorting problem. It had zero flair. Over time, when local game stores started carrying our gear, we realized that the eye wants something too. So, we added the stone textures. We added the banners. We invested time in the packaging.
But the hierarchy never changed. We build a product to solve a specific problem first. Only when the mechanics are rock-solid do we look at the aesthetics. In fact, we once designed a prototype from the ground up just to look beautiful. It looked incredible. But it failed our functional tests at the table. That product is not in our store today, and it never will be.
If it does not make the game better, it dies.
The Problem with "Dice Pushers"
This is exactly what bothers us about the modern flood of AI gear and dropshipped accessories. There is no deep problem-solving involved.
A massive, intricately painted DM screen might look amazing on a shelf. A glowing set of custom dice is a fun novelty. But do these things actually make you play better? Do they speed up combat? Do they help the DM manage five different monster stat blocks?
Usually, the answer is no. They are just pretty distractions. And when you are a DM trying to juggle a dozen different things at once, the last thing you need is another distraction.
We love the process of creation too much to outsource it to an algorithm or a factory halfway across the world. We genuinely enjoy figuring out the exact texture for a 3D-printed tracker. We love the messy, human process of drawing a goblin cave by hand. A computer can generate a perfect map in three seconds, but it cannot understand the pacing of an ambush or the exact amount of grid space a party needs to maneuver. Human design matters because it anticipates human gameplay.
Building for the Guild
At the end of the day, we are just two DMs making tools for other DMs. We could probably increase our margins if we stopped caring about the craft. We could pump out generic accessories and become just another dice pusher.
But we would rather earn a little less money and sleep well at night, knowing we are making tools and adventures that you actually need. Tools that earn their place on your table.
Keep the phones away. Keep the table clean. Keep rolling.